Family Law • Rights, Safety & Procedure
Matrimonial Disputes & Domestic Violence
IPC Section 498A / BNS Sections 85–86 Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005
Balanced, practical guidance for spouses and families dealing with cruelty allegations, arrest concerns, maintenance, residence, Stridhan, child custody, settlement and legal protection.
Search results update as you type • 28 questions available
Questions 1–28
Matrimonial and domestic violence guidance
1My wife has filed a false case of 498A (dowry harassment) against me and my family. What should I do?
Obtain case-specific legal advice immediately. If there is a genuine apprehension of arrest, your advocate may consider anticipatory bail. Preserve lawfully obtained material such as messages, emails, financial records, medical records and witness details, and cooperate with every lawful investigation notice. Do not fabricate evidence, threaten anyone or attempt to influence witnesses.
2Is there immediate arrest in a 498A case?
Arrest is not automatic. Under the principles stated by the Supreme Court in Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, the police must examine the statutory necessity for arrest and record reasons. A notice to appear may be issued under Section 35 of the BNSS (formerly Section 41A of the CrPC). However, arrest remains possible where the legal conditions are met, so comply with notices and obtain prompt advice.
3Can I file a counter-case against my wife?
Only when independent facts and reliable evidence support a lawful claim. Depending on the circumstances, remedies may include a complaint concerning false information or a false charge, defamation proceedings, or matrimonial relief such as divorce. A retaliatory or unsupported case can be harmful, so have an advocate assess the evidence first.
4My wife has also filed a case under the Domestic Violence Act. What can happen in that case?
Proceedings under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act are primarily relief-oriented. A Magistrate may grant protection, residence, monetary relief, temporary custody, compensation and interim orders. The initial application does not itself mean arrest, but breach of a protection order is an offence and can have criminal consequences.
5My wife has filed a maintenance case. How much might I have to pay?
There is no fixed percentage. The court considers the disclosed income, assets, liabilities, reasonable needs, standard of living, dependants, childcare responsibilities and conduct relevant under the applicable law. A spouse's earnings are relevant but do not automatically defeat maintenance. Summary maintenance is now addressed by Section 144 of the BNSS (formerly Section 125 of the CrPC).
6If my wife left the matrimonial home voluntarily, can maintenance still be awarded?
It depends on the facts and the provision invoked. The court examines whether there was sufficient reason to live separately, whether there was neglect or refusal to maintain, and the evidence from both sides. Living separately without sufficient cause may affect some maintenance claims, but it is not an automatic bar to every form of relief.
7Can a 498A case be settled?
A genuine settlement may be reached through mediation or negotiations. Because the offence is non-compoundable, settlement alone does not automatically end the FIR. The parties may approach the High Court for quashing, and the court will examine whether the settlement is voluntary, lawful and appropriate in the facts of the case.
8My elderly parents have also been named in the FIR. What should we do?
Age or relationship does not create an automatic exemption. However, vague or omnibus allegations without a specific role may support anticipatory bail, discharge or a petition for quashing, depending on the record. Preserve proof of separate residence, health conditions and other relevant facts, and obtain individual legal advice for every accused person.
9What is Stridhan, and must it be returned?
Stridhan generally includes property and gifts given to a woman before, at or after marriage over which she has ownership. It is her exclusive property and must be returned to her on demand. The parties should prepare a documented inventory and use a traceable, lawful method for return to avoid later disputes.
10How can I file for divorce?
A divorce petition is filed under the personal law applicable to the marriage, usually before the Family Court having territorial jurisdiction. Grounds may include cruelty, desertion or other statutory grounds. The petition should be supported by relevant pleadings and documents; mediation and interim applications may also arise during the case.
11Can elderly parents obtain relief in a 498A case?
Yes, where the allegations are general, no specific incident or demand is attributed to them, or the record shows separate residence or minimal involvement, these facts may support bail, discharge or quashing. Relief is not automatic and depends on the allegations, evidence and procedural stage.
12What documents should a husband preserve when defending an allegedly false dowry case?
Preserve complete and unedited chats, emails, call-detail information obtained lawfully, bank transactions, proof of residence, travel records, medical records, prior complaints, mediation papers and names of relevant witnesses. Keep original devices and backups where possible. Do not hack accounts, secretly alter files or destroy unfavourable material.
13How can I report cruelty or dowry harassment by my husband and in-laws?
Give a clear written complaint describing specific incidents, dates, persons involved, demands, injuries, threats and available evidence to the local police or women police station. A copy may also be sent to the senior police officer. Where domestic violence relief is needed, contact the Protection Officer, a service provider or the Magistrate. Seek immediate police or medical assistance if there is danger.
14What relief can I seek under the Domestic Violence Act?
Depending on the facts, you may seek a protection order, residence order, monetary relief, medical expenses, compensation, temporary custody of children, return of property or Stridhan, and urgent interim or ex parte orders. The relief granted depends on the evidence and the specific application.
15I need maintenance from my husband. Where should I apply?
Maintenance may be sought before the competent Family Court or Magistrate under Section 144 of the BNSS (formerly Section 125 of the CrPC), under applicable matrimonial or personal law, and as monetary relief under the Domestic Violence Act. Your advocate can identify the correct forum and request interim maintenance where available.
16My Stridhan is at my in-laws' house. How can I recover it?
Prepare a detailed list supported by bills, photographs, wedding records, messages or witnesses, and make a written demand for return. Relief for return of Stridhan may be sought under the Domestic Violence Act. Where the legal ingredients are present, a complaint for criminal breach of trust may also be considered. Do not attempt forcible recovery.
17Can I obtain custody of my children?
Yes, you may seek interim custody in appropriate Domestic Violence Act proceedings or file a separate custody or guardianship case. The child's welfare is the paramount consideration. Age, schooling, safety, caregiving history, stability and the child's wishes, where appropriate, may all be considered; custody is not automatic for either parent.
18The police are not registering my FIR. What should I do?
Keep proof of submission and send the complaint to the senior police officer through a traceable method. If no effective action follows, you may approach the competent Magistrate for directions to investigate under Section 175(3) of the BNSS (formerly Section 156(3) of the CrPC), subject to current procedural requirements. An advocate can help prepare the supporting affidavit and documents.
19Can I obtain free legal aid?
Yes. Women are among the categories eligible to seek free legal services through the District Legal Services Authority (DLSA). Other eligible persons may also apply under the Legal Services Authorities Act. Visit the DLSA office at the district court complex and carry identity documents and available case papers.
20My husband is threatening divorce. Can he force me out of the shared household?
A spouse should not be forcibly dispossessed without due process. Under the Domestic Violence Act, a woman may seek protection of her right to reside in a shared household and request a residence order or alternate accommodation. This is a right of residence, not necessarily a transfer of ownership, and the precise relief depends on the facts and property arrangements.
21How much does it cost to pursue a matrimonial or domestic violence case?
Costs vary with the forum, number of proceedings, evidence, hearings and the advocate engaged. Depending on the applicable law, a party may seek interim maintenance, litigation expenses or monetary relief. Eligible persons can also approach the DLSA for free legal aid rather than delaying urgent protection.
22I am being pressured to settle. What should I do?
A settlement must be informed and voluntary. Do not sign terms you do not understand or accept pressure, threats or unsafe private meetings. Tell your advocate, mediator or the court about the pressure, retain copies of every draft, and ensure that payment, custody, property, withdrawal and quashing terms are clear and realistically enforceable.
23What are the most important reliefs available to a wife in a domestic violence case?
Key reliefs may include protection from violence and communication, residence rights or alternate accommodation, monthly financial support, medical expenses, compensation, temporary custody of children, return of Stridhan and litigation-related relief. Urgent interim orders may be requested where immediate protection is needed.
24Can a husband remove his wife from the shared household?
He should not use force or self-help to evict her. A woman may seek a residence order under the Domestic Violence Act even where ownership is disputed, if the premises qualify as a shared household on the facts. The court may protect residence, regulate access, restrain dispossession or direct alternate accommodation or rent.
25What is the difference between a 498A case and a Domestic Violence Act case?
Section 498A of the IPC, and the corresponding cruelty provisions in Sections 85–86 of the BNS, concern criminal liability for cruelty by a husband or his relatives. The Domestic Violence Act is primarily a protective and relief-based law providing residence, protection, monetary, custody and compensation orders. Both proceedings can arise from the same facts and may continue simultaneously.
26Does employment automatically disqualify a wife from maintenance?
No. Employment by itself does not automatically bar maintenance. The court compares actual income, earning capacity where legally relevant, reasonable needs, standard of living, childcare duties, liabilities and the financial position of both parties. A significant and sufficient independent income may affect the amount.
27My husband's actual income is being concealed. What can I do?
Ask the court for a complete income-and-assets disclosure and production of relevant records. Depending on the case, salary slips, income-tax returns, bank statements, company records, property information and reliable evidence of lifestyle may be sought. Use lawful court procedures rather than attempting unauthorized access to accounts or devices.
28Can a husband seek maintenance from his wife?
In some proceedings, including under gender-neutral maintenance provisions of certain matrimonial laws, a husband without sufficient independent income may seek interim support or permanent alimony from a financially capable wife. Entitlement is not automatic and depends on the applicable personal law, income, health, earning capacity, conduct where relevant and the specific facts.
Try a shorter term or search for words such as “bail,” “maintenance,” “Stridhan,” “custody,” or “DLSA.”